Friday, April 28, 2017
Carrie Fisher: Princess, Rebel, and Brave Comic Voice
As a fan of Carrie Fisher since childhood, I was excited to read this book initially, because Fisher had led an extremely interesting life and had an awesome sense of humor. As I delved into the first sections, however, I found myself wholeheartedly disappointed.
If you have a subscription to the New York Times, then you have probably already read this book, or at least most of it. The book consists only of articles on Fisher published by The New York Times between July 13, 1977, and January 5, 2017.
I, however, disagree. There was no transition between the articles. The articles were in order from most recently published to least recently, and as the articles became more and more spread apart, this left the story feeling more and more disjointed. As the story was merely the articles of many different people, there were several different voices and opinions of the same person, and no voice ever leaves you with a feeling of clarity.
The biggest downfall, however, was that the story had no forward, prologue, prelude, after thoughts, epilogue, or final words to tie the stories and time frames together. You as the reader merely see many different variances of Carrie Fisher through the eyes of several very different people.
Don’t get me wrong. The articles were great on their own, each well-written and poignant, but they lacked a solid fluidity of voice, idea, or pace altogether. I love Carrie Fisher, and I love to read, but this book just isn’t worth the $2.99 price tag.
Published by the New York Times at the end March 2017 via the Nook and Kindle stores, this book, much to my surprise, had very few reviews or ratings. There were no customer reviews on the book in the Nook store, and only one customer review available in the Kindle store. The reviewer did not leave their name, but Amazon verified they had purchased the book before giving it a rating of five out of five stars and a brief comment, saying “Very interesting series of articles made into a book.” In fact, this is the only review I was able to find on any sight: the book just wasn’t something to write home about.
Amazon advertises the book as, "a selection of stories, reviews and interviews from The New York Times archives chronicling the life of Carrie Fisher."
If you want to remember Carrie Fisher or get to know her a little more personally, read her books. Carrie Fisher wrote several books before her death, and not only are they refreshingly blunt about life as a celebrity and life with mental illness, they are also well-written and funny, unlike this memoir by the New York Times.
At a Glance:
-Title: Carrie Fisher: Princess, Rebel, and Brave Comic Voice
-What is it: Memoir of Carrie Fisher
-Who is it by: The New York Times
-Summary: The book is a compilation of articles by various writers of the New York Times that all go over the life of Carrie Fisher
-Rating: Two out of five stars
-Number of Pages: 121
-Cost: $2.99 in the Kindle and Nook stores
- What others said: Five out of five stars
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment